BMW X2 vs DS No4: the French fashionista takes on a Bavarian bruiser

The DS wasn’t far behind its rival, returning 44.7mpg, so running costs will be similar. Servicing charges for the DS look likely to be a little cheaper, and the No4’s list price is lower (even with more standard kit) than the BMW’s.

Considering how large and imposing both of these cars are, practicality isn’t really a strong point. Both have a fairly high boot lip and narrow storage area; this is the price you pay for style, because the sloping boot lines and raked windscreens on these models reduce the room inside. Rear-seat space isn’t massive either, but there’s plenty of room for children, so either will work as a family car.

Blind-spot warning and adaptive cruise control are pricey optional extras on the X2, but are standard-fit on the No4. Adaptive cruise control isn’t for everyone, but blind-spot warning is handy. 

Visibility is a weak point on both cars; the BMW’s raked windscreen and high shoulder line limit what you can see close around the car. The DS feels a little easier to park, but the large main mirror and small windscreen limit forward visibility a little.

Both brands offer the same three-year warranty, which is the bare minimum in the UK. While BMW’s 1.5-litre engine seems to be faring well over the years it’s been available in other cars from the brand, the DS’s 1.2-litre unit has developed a poor reputation over a similar period. But past problems were caused by a timing belt that’s been replaced by a timing chain. Correct servicing will give peace of mind.

Despite being more expensive than its rival, especially when you consider what’s missing from the standard kit list, the X2 feels worth the extra cash when you’re behind the wheel. It’s more comfortable more of the time, while also being more engaging to drive and roomier inside. It’s also the more practical choice, too, despite the undeniably bold styling. 

Original source BMW X2 vs DS No4: the French fashionista takes on a Bavarian bruiser

Back to home