Does Double Cleansing Really Make A Difference? I Tried It For 2 Weeks

Image may contain Head Person Face Photography Portrait Adult Body Part and Neck

As a beauty writer and a make-up lover, a robust cleansing routine is an occupational necessity. Previously, though, a cotton round doused with micellar water, a quick lather with a gel cleanser and a hydrating moisturiser was all I needed to keep my skin happy. Then, everything changed. When I moved out of the city – and doubled the length of my morning commute – the extended time spent underground travelling into work sent my skin into meltdown.

Sign Up To The British Vogue Beauty Newsletter

As anyone who lives in a city knows, the air isn’t exactly clean to begin with. Thanks to vehicle emissions, heating and air conditioning systems and construction, there’s all sorts of debris circulating. A study by the University of Cambridge found that the issue intensifies on the Underground, as “pollution particles are suspended for long periods, due to poor ventilation, particularly on station platforms”.

It wasn’t long before I noticed a downturn in the general health of my skin and an uptick in pesky, pore-blocking comedones. In this new reality, my quick and easy cleansing regimen would no longer cut it – I needed an overhaul. I decided to commit to diligent double cleansing in the interests of keeping my face grime-free.

What is double cleansing?

Double cleansing is a skincare method that involves just two products: an oil cleanser and a water-based cleanser. The idea is to first break down stubborn make-up and waterproof formulas with an oil or balm cleanser. Then, a water-based (gel, foaming or otherwise) cleanser is used to thoroughly clean the skin and remove any lingering residue left behind from make-up, SPF or skincare products. This two-stage approach helps to prevent blocked pores and potential skin irritation.

Some people choose to use the same cleanser twice, though this will depend on your skin type.

Why should you double cleanse?

A single cleanse may not be sufficient to effectively get rid of everything on your face. If you’ve ever done a single lather and rinse, only to pat your face dry with a towel and find large splotches of make-up or grime, chances are you’ve not done a thorough enough cleanse. Double cleansing – when using oil followed by a water-based formula – means a better chance of breaking down the different particles.

If we follow the “like dissolves like” rule, oils work to break down other oils, like concealer, foundation and certain mascaras. The second cleanse can then get rid of whatever’s left, like grime left from pollution, remnants of SPF and old skincare. You wouldn’t brush your teeth without toothpaste – this is similar.

“A double cleanse is important because the first cleanse has to dissolve oil well. Especially if you’re using heavy-duty products such as longwear and waterproof make-up,” dermatologist Dr Beibei Du-Harpur explains. The second step should always be a gentle, hydrating cleanse to prevent stripping the skin of essential natural oils, she notes.

Below, I outline how my two-week experiment panned out.

Week one

I have oily skin and, naturally, was sceptical of putting yet more oil on my face. And yet, I instantly noticed how smoothly my make-up washed off my face when I did. Elemis’s Pro-Collagen Black Cherry Cleansing Balm is a delight to apply, and I found that I barely scratched the surface of the tub during the first week of use. Next, I followed up with either the Sarah Chapman Rapid Radiance cleanser (on days when I wore heavier make-up or was out of the house longer) or Cetaphil’s Gentle Skin Cleanser.

Image may contain: Face, Head, Person, Bottle, Cosmetics, Perfume, and Aftershave

Elemis Pro Collagen Black Cherry Cleansing Balm

Image may contain: Bottle, Lotion, Cosmetics, and Perfume

Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser Wash

After cleansing, I dutifully followed up with two moisturisers. The La Roche-Posay Effaclar Duo went on problem areas – blemishes and pimples – while the Cetaphil Daily Hydrating Moisturiser went everywhere else on my face. I allowed the products to sink in for around 10 to 20 minutes before climbing into bed and drifting off to sleep.

Image may contain: Bottle, Lotion, Dynamite, and Weapon

La Roche Posay Effaclar Duo+M Anti Blemish Gel Moisturiser

By day seven, I noticed that my skin had begun to feel smoother and I was able to zap troublesome under-the-skin spots with pimple patches once they surfaced. My skin did still feel slightly dull (and I still had a few blocked pores too), but overall, I felt refreshed and confident that I had eliminated any lingering pollutants.

Image may contain: Advertisement, and Poster

Hero Mighty Patch Invisible+ Spot Patches

“Not only do these pimple patches flatten spots within hours of wear, but they also lay flush against the skin with an undetectable finish. Best of all, you can dab concealer over them for seamless coverage of unsightly breakouts.“ –

Week two

During the second week, I followed the same method but trialled a different oil cleanser. This time I went in with the Sunday Riley Aquamarine Melt Cleansing Gel-Balm, which is dispensed via a handy pump – making it really easy after a long day or night out, when all you want to do is hop into bed. For my second cleanse, I continued using Cetaphil, both the face wash and the moisturiser, noting just how soft the combination made my skin feel. By the end of the week, my face was noticeably calmer and devoid of the open comedones that had plagued it 14 days earlier.

Image may contain: Bottle, Lotion, Cosmetics, Perfume, and Shampoo
Image may contain: Bottle, Lotion, Shaker, and Cosmetics

One side-effect I am monitoring is that my skin does seem to look oilier during the day. It hasn’t led to any breakouts, but it has, at times, been quite visible. It’s likely that my skin is just getting used to my new routine, and to be honest, I’d take a slightly “glowier” complexion over an irritated skin barrier any day.

Final thoughts

Overall, I’d recommend double cleansing for those who wear make-up or a particularly heavy-duty daily SPF. Dr Du-Harpur agrees, sharing that the combination is very effective “for removing anything that is designed to grip the skin”. If you don’t usually wear make-up, and don’t live or work in an urban area, it’s fine to just stick with a single thorough cleanse.

A step-by-step guide to double cleansing

First, pick two cleansers that you like the formulations of. That might be an oil or balm cleanser designed for sensitive skin – or whatever type of skin you have. Creams and milks are worthy first-step options, too, when you’ve left your skin bare from product. Wash your face with this cleanser, focusing on small circles and reaching the areas around the edge of the face, into the hairline and around the nose and inner eye.

Then, pick a second cleanser that leaves your skin feeling clean but not squeaky or tight. This could be something with active ingredients to help tackle skin concerns. If texture is your issue, a cleanser with smoothing alpha-hydroxy acids might be something to prioritise here. Or, for improved skin tone, vitamin C. Follow with your usual skincare routine.

What are the benefits of double cleansing?

“Cleansing twice helps to prevent clogged pores, breakouts and dullness,” says Dr Anjali Mahto, consultant dermatologist and founder of Self London. “And it can be as simple as using a micellar water followed by your normal cleanser.”

While Mahto is a proponent of micellar water as a first step, the wider jury is still out on this. If you don’t wear make-up, or need to break down heavy products, then micellar water followed by a water-based cleanser should be fine, but it’s best to see how your skin fares before sticking to it. Make-up wipes are to be avoided for their tendency to smear make-up and grime around the face – not actually remove it.

Should I wash my face with just water?

No, you shouldn’t. Water alone is not sufficient to thoroughly cleanse the skin of make-up, SPF, and the general grime of navigating daily life.

Is there any benefit to triple cleansing?

A triple cleanse is, in almost all cases, unnecessary. Overdoing it can also cause skin barrier impairment: “When you introduce surfactants to the skin – which are present in cleansers and can dissolve oil – you are risking disrupting the skin barrier a little bit.” And then you’d be right back to square one – when all we want is to maintain a healthy, glowy and hydrated skin microbiome.

Is it OK to double cleanse every day?

If your usual routine is the same – from make-up to being in polluted environments – then, yes, it’s fine to double cleanse every day. There are a few caveats. If you notice your skin becoming irritated, showing new signs of dryness or feeling , strip your routine back: one cleanser, used morning and night, gentle moisturiser and sunscreen during the day. Irritation means re-evaluation.

Image may contain: Bottle, Cosmetics, Perfume, and Lotion

Shu Uemura Ultime8 Sublime Beauty Cleansing Oil

Image may contain: Bottle, Cosmetics, and Lipstick

Trinny London Be Your Best Enzyme Balm Cleanser 80ml

Image may contain: Bottle, Face, Head, Person, and Cosmetics

RMS Beauty Coconut Clean Cleansing Balm

Image may contain: Bottle, Lotion, Tape, and Cosmetics

Naturium Fermented Camellia Creamy Cleansing Oil

Original source Does Double Cleansing Really Make A Difference? I Tried It For 2 Weeks

Back to home