
It can be tough, being a celebrity. Hear me out! Sure, it comes with money, acclaim and unfettered access to luxury fashion. But it also tends to mean millions of people feel entitled to vocalise their opinion on your looks, which is when things inevitably tend to get a little trickier.
Particularly for women, of course. And particularly when self-appointed social media detectives start scrutinising every inch of a high-profile woman’s face, speculating about what she may or may not have had “done”. Is it a facelift or filler? A little Botox or upper blepharoplasty? It’s safe to say that no tweak, tightening or treatment – be it real or imagined – goes unnoticed, or increasingly, unremarked upon.
One star who has found herself at the centre of online scrutiny this week is former British cover star Florence Pugh. In an Instagram Reel titled, “Is it just me or does Hollywood hate round faces?”, a writer compared an older photograph of Pugh with a more recent one, suggesting the 30-year-old East of Eden star’s face shape had changed in the interim.

“… People are saying that Florence Pugh has fallen victim to Hollywood’s war on round faces,” the writer says. “Don’t get me wrong, Florence Pugh still looks beautiful, but Hollywood seems to have this thing against softer features.” The reel goes on to discuss the “sculpted” and “snatched” look that has become the beauty ideal in the entertainment world, suggesting that women are increasingly pursuing sharper jawlines as a result. The clip caught the attention of Pugh herself, who commented on the post.
“Guys, I turned 30,” the actor wrote. “I’m a woman. [Bodies] and faces change. It’s not that deep, the fact that people can’t even tell between what’s aging and what’s surgery is disturbing. Sadly puppy fluff doesn’t last forever.”

Pugh’s exasperated response illustrates just how exhausting it is to be a woman in the public eye – a woman full stop – where you’re damned if you do and damned if you don’t. (Pugh sadly has previous experience with internet trolls – she memorably told online body-shamers to “grow up” after they weighed in on her dress for the Valentino Haute Couture show in Rome.) On the one hand, women are celebrated for embracing the entirely normal ageing process. (Take Olivia Colman and Sarah Jessica Parker, for example, who have been praised for their chic silver hair.) On the other, they risk being accused of “letting themselves go” if they don’t continue to look exactly as they did when they first entered the spotlight. And if they do choose to have a little help along the way, as is entirely their prerogative? That gets dissected ad nauseam, too.
Of course, celebrities shouldn’t be exempt from conversations about beauty standards, and the more we question the normalisation of cosmetic procedures, the more we can make natural ageing feel, well, normal. But there’s a difference between a healthy conversation about unrealistic beauty ideals and picking apart an individual woman’s appearance.
Speculating about what someone has or hasn’t had done is just as damaging as criticising lines, wrinkles or any other natural signs of ageing. Both reinforce the idea that a woman’s face is fair game. What we’re really doing? Perpetuating the same impossible beauty standards that hurt us all in the long run.