One Vogue Editor’s Quest To Find The Perfect Pair Of Maternity Jeans

Image may contain Clothing Coat Jacket Pants Blazer Jeans Adult Person Footwear Shoe Electronics and Mobile Phone

Vogue’ In The Market For, glimpse into the team’s wishlists. Be it a vintage runway piece, a perfect white shirt or even an accent chair, each month we ask an editor to share one item they’ve been hunting for, plus all the best contenders they discovered during their search.

Hello, my name is Joy, and I am currently waging a one-woman battle against a crescent moon-shaped sliver of skin located just above my waistband. IYKYK. You see, at the time of writing, I am a spherical 36 weeks pregnant (never has a lunar metaphor been so apt) and, try as I may, I cannot make the outfit geometry work – a successful top-to-trouser ratio seems to be a mathematical impossibility.

Yes, the winking belly is one of the many joys of navigating one’s wardrobe in the third trimester, particularly as someone who has refused (some might say stubbornly so) to buy anything that has even the faintest whisper of “maternity”. I’ve stretched stretchy fabrics to their limits and put elasticated waistbands through their paces, but there came a point where even I had to concede that my baggiest jeans, perilously held together by a single hairband, had reached their expiry date.

Featured in this article

Image may contain: Clothing, Pants, Shorts, and Jeans
Best for: a cropped fit
Isabella Oliver Organic Cotton Maternity Wide-Leg Jeans
Jump to review
Image may contain: Clothing, Jeans, and Pants
Best for: comfort
Seraphine Mid-Blue Maternity Underbump Loose Boyfriend Jeans
Jump to review
Image may contain: Clothing, Pants, Jeans, and Shorts
Best for: belly supportJump to review

So with much huffing and puffing (and that was just to get off the sofa), I typed “maternity jeans” into Google, expecting to be presented with a tableau of bump-hugging, skinny-jean-clad models padding barefoot along an AI-generated beach – or something. But, turns out that the pregnancy jeans market has, in fact, moved on since I was an 11-year old leafing through the Next directory; there are now a whole host of brands that deliver designs I would happily add to my wardrobe.

But what are the gold-standard maternity jeans? I decided to take the hit for pregnant people everywhere and road-test some of the most popular brands on the market. I wore every pair for a full day in the office – inclusive of: cramped tube commute, assorted press events and many hours sat at a desk – to test them on everything from comfort and fit, to style and slippage (the belly crescent loomed large, in every sense). Scroll down to read my verdict.

Image may contain Clothing Pants Coat Jeans Adult Person Jacket Electronics Mobile Phone Phone Footwear and Shoe
Image may contain Clothing Pants Jeans Coat Adult Person Footwear Shoe Jacket Knitwear and Sweater

My first impressions of Hatch’s Relaxed Cuffed Maternity Jeans is that the brand has clearly put thought into the design: if it wasn’t for the discrete triangles of elastic sitting either side of the waistband, you’d never know that they were maternity (which, of course, is a big tick for me). The jeans have a nice amount of slouch: they go from a straight fit around the hips and thighs and widen into a looser leg from the knee downwards, ending in a cute turn-up, which looks great over a winter boot.

I stuck to my usual UK 10 and would say they are true to size, however shorter girls should note that the leg length is generous – I’m 5’7” and they graze the floor. My only reservation is I found myself having to hoik up the jeans, toddler-style, pretty regularly throughout the day, so had to install a bodysuit base-layer to mitigate the ever-widening belly crescent. Mind the gap indeed.

Shop the jeans
Image may contain: Clothing, Jeans, Pants, Footwear, High Heel, and Shoe

The Relaxed Cuffed Maternity Jean

Image may contain Clothing Pants Jeans Blazer Coat Jacket Adult Person Footwear and Shoe
Image may contain Clothing Pants Blazer Coat Jacket Jeans Adult Person Formal Wear Suit Footwear and Shoe

Out of all the styles I tried on, Seraphine’s Boyfriend jeans felt the most generous: fit, length and silhouette-wise. Not only did it make them super comfortable for a long day in the office, but it also meant I didn’t have to undo any buttons when sitting at my desk. Also, bonus points for the hidden button-fasten in the waistband, which allows you to make further adjustments to the size.

As mentioned, they were one of the longer pairs I tried on – the hemlines skimmed the floor in flat loafers – so something for petites to bear in mind. And, as was the case with all the low-slung styles, I did have to watch out for the belly gap, but the lack of slippage (and the addition of a longer, looser top) meant this wasn’t too much of an issue.

Shop the jeans
Image may contain: Clothing, Jeans, and Pants

Mid-Blue Maternity Underbump Loose Boyfriend Jeans

Isabella Oliver Maternity Wide-Leg Jeans

Image may contain Clothing Coat Jacket Pants Jeans Adult Person and Blazer
Image may contain Clothing Pants Jeans Coat Jacket Adult and Person

Isabella Oliver’s maternity jeans were the shortest in my lineup, making them great for anyone craving a crop. The proportions did, however, work with an old pair of heeled boots that I wear on repeat in the winter months. I’m wearing a UK 10 and would say they are true to size – I only experienced minor slippage throughout the day. It’s also worth noting that the elasticated part of the waistband extends all the way round, from the front belt loops to the back.

Fit-wise, the brand describes the jeans as a “wide leg”, however I would say that they are more of a straight-leg – but this ended up being a selling point, as they have that classic “Levi’s 501” feel that look great with everything.

Shop the jeans
Image may contain: Clothing, Pants, Shorts, and Jeans

Organic Cotton Maternity Wide-Leg Jeans

Image may contain Clothing Pants Jeans Coat Person Jacket Blazer Scarf Footwear and Shoe
Image may contain Clothing Pants Jeans Coat Adult Person Jacket Electronics Mobile Phone and Phone

This was one of two pairs of maternity jeans I tried on that featured an elasticated panel. At first, the mere sight of a belly panel gave me the ick – there is something quite jarring about the fake waistband and pull-on style – but I quickly realised that there were upsides. Firstly, it offers great coverage when tops ride up, and secondly, it gives extra support, which is always welcome in the third trimester. Thirdly, the Simon Cowell waistline means there is zero risk of slippage when going about your day.

The main downside? They’re not the most comfortable for sitting down in for long periods of time (an inevitability when in the office), and the faux button means you can’t even attempt a cheeky under-desk unbuttoning. When it comes to silhouette, the jeans are more of baggy flare than wide-leg, possibly due to the elasticated panel, which creates a tighter fit on the hips and bum. I’m wearing a UK 10 here.

Image may contain: Clothing, Pants, Jeans, and Shorts
Image may contain Clothing Pants Jeans Coat Jacket Adult Person Footwear and Shoe
Image may contain Clothing Pants Jeans Adult Person Coat Jacket Electronics Mobile Phone Phone Footwear and Shoe

Original source One Vogue Editor’s Quest To Find The Perfect Pair Of Maternity Jeans

Back to home