
You know when someone says something so obvious that you instantly think, “I should have thought of that”? Well, that exact thing happened to me while I was scrolling through TikTok a few months ago. I came across a caption that read: “Why are you not following make-up tutorials from creators who have the same colour eyes as you?”
’s top make-up for brown eyes at a glance:
It was so simple, yet it made complete sense. You can’t expect the same eye-enhancing results as someone with completely different colouring. It was a eureka moment. From then on, I started seeking out fellow brown-eyed girls and following their make-up tutorials – and honestly, it has completely transformed my make-up routine.
“A neutral colour, brown eyes can suit a very wide range of looks,” says make-up artist Claudia Neacsu. “Colour definitely makes brown eyes pop beautifully – like green, blue or purple. I also adore pairing brown eyes with really warm shades of burgundy; I feel like it makes the eyes look warm and somehow golden.”
Bobbi Brown concurs, agreeing that “Brown eyes can wear almost any colour. I love cool neutrals, icy silver and rich chocolates – they bring out the colour in brown eyes. Navy, deep plum and ivy liners are also beautiful when you want a little contrast, but you can never go wrong with classic espresso or black.”
With expert tips and tricks in mind, from the best mascara shades to eyeshadow palettes and liner colourways, below find the best make-up for brown eyes, and the techniques to make them pop.
When it comes to eyeshadow, “I don’t think there’s any colour that doesn’t look good on brown eyes, but depending on your skin tone, different colours might look better,” explains Neacsu. “One universally flattering colour that works amazingly on brown eyes regardless of the skin tone is burgundy. I also adore olive green on brown eyes as it makes your look kind of mysterious. Colours that would make brown eyes pop most would be: blue, purple and green.” Make-up artist Naima Bremer agrees with the versatile nature of brown eyes, comparing them to “wearing a black outfit. It just always works.” She adds, “If you want to bring out the brown in the eyes, I love using either a purple, sapphire blue or a terracotta brown.”
While Brown has a penchant for navy, deep plum and ivy liners, it is classic black and brown that are the unanimously preferred shades among the experts. Neacsu says, “I love a monochrome moment, so I love pairing brown eyes with a warm brown eyeliner and a warm brown mascara. It looks very sophisticated and works very well for daytime as it’s less harsh than black.” Bremer adds, “You can go both ways; black will contrast it beautifully, and a brown will look softer and sometimes will help make the brown in the eyes pop.” Neacsu also spotlights burgundy alongside Brown’s navy blue.
Brown prefers a classic approach to mascara, detailing that she will never tire of pitch-black hues: “It’s classic and gives brown eyes the biggest pop.” However, she has recently been converted. “I’ve started wearing brown mascara, and now I understand why people love it. A rich brown gives you a softer look while still defining the lashes beautifully. On brown eyes, it creates a cool, monochromatic look that feels very downtown and chic.” Bremer encourages getting creative with colour, especially blue, as it’s “fun to do something other than black.” Neacsu is also a huge fan of coloured mascara: “I think it’s one of the most underrated make-up products, to be honest. Shades like warm brown, burgundy, or blue look gorgeous on brown eyes.”
What technique makes brown eyes appear larger or more defined?
Both Neacsu and Bremer suggest using a nude-beige liner on the waterline to open the eyes. Or, according to Bremer, another hack is to add a warm bronze hue, especially “one that has that luminosity to accentuate the brown, but it will also catch a bit of light because of the shimmer particles. So if you’re worried about a darker pencil closing the eye, this is also a great option. And the warmth of that terracotta bronze makes the brown eyes pop.” It doesn’t have to be a shimmer shade either. Neacsu believes a light shade of brown will do the trick, or if you want your eyes to look more defined, “add a brown/black or burgundy eyeliner on the waterline as well as on top of your lash line as eyeliner. That would sculpt and define the eyes beautifully.”
Are there any classic make-up looks that never go out of style for brown eyes?
A timeless eye make-up look, details Brown, consists of a defined eye, which “always looks modern paired with a neutral shadow when liner is applied close to the lashes and with plenty of mascara. I also love a warm bronze eye with a healthy flush of colour on the cheeks and a nude lip. It’s simple, flattering and never goes out of style.” For Neacsu, when it comes to the best make-up for brown eyes, you can’t go wrong with a soft, warm brown smoky eye, but if you’re looking to do something different, mix it up with burgundy.
What are the most common make-up mistakes people with brown eyes make?
Don’t underestimate the power of a brown eye. Neacsu wants to stress that they are “special and beautiful.” She says, “I think people often believe that brown eyes are boring or underwhelming, which couldn’t be more wrong.” Bremer also stresses avoiding applying a bone shade and leaving it at that. Instead, bring “dimension to the eye with either some shadow and the right tone of brown.”
How can you avoid making their eye make-up look too harsh or too muted?
“It’s all about balance and blending,” Brown tells me. “Keep the darkest colour close to the lash line and blend it out so there are no hard edges. If the look feels too muted, add definition with liner and mascara or a touch of brightness at the inner corners.”
What types of eyeshadow finishes are best for brown eyes?
This depends on the look that you want. Whether you opt for matte, shimmer, satin or metallic shades, there are benefits to each. Brown breaks it down: “Matte and satin shadows are great for everyday definition, while shimmer adds light and makes brown eyes sparkle. I like metallics as an accent on the lid rather than all over. The most modern eye usually has a mix of texture and dimension.” Neacsu leans on a satin “when I am lazy as it’s the easiest to work with,” but emphasises to play around with all, while Bremer says it also depends on the shade: “A shimmer and metallic in the right jewel tones or terracotta browns will make them pop more than a matte shadow will.”
Meet the experts















