
What is sexual wellness? Is it, as some insist, purely about pleasure? About connecting to our own desires and being able to communicate that to potential partners? About consent, privacy, safety, bodily integrity? Perhaps? Or is it political – is it about sexual health services, STI education, access to contraception, making our own reproductive choices, the prevention of sexual violence? What about sexual justice? And our relationship to our own sexuality, and how that is met by others?
In simple terms, “Sexual wellness is the pursuit of improved sexual wellbeing, rather than merely the absence of sexual challenges or dissatisfaction,” says Dr Karen Gurney, a clinical psychologist and author who writes about desire. She cites Kirstin Mitchell, professor of social science and public health at the University of Glasgow, as describing how sexual wellbeing sits alongside sexual pleasure, sexual health and sexual justice to create a broader, holistic concept of sexual wellness. “Sexual wellness therefore,” says Gurney, “represents a journey towards sexual authenticity, freedom and pleasure.”
Another question then arises. Should this journey be commodified?
Since Goop mainstreamed the market in 2015 with its Sex Dust, and later jade vaginal eggs, the term “sexual wellness” has been employed to sell us products ranging from vibrators to “tribulus terrestris extract” in an industry that, by 2036, is expected to surpass $1 trillion globally. By anyone’s standards, that’s a lot of lube. It’s likely that, even if you don’t identify it as such, you’ve probably already invested in the sexual wellness industry. It has grown to include sex toys, vaginal wipes, Cialis (a medication to treat erectile dysfunction), “fur oil” (to soften pubic hair), multivitamins designed for performance and pleasure, red-light treatments that supposedly target everything from vaginal tissue health to testosterone production, and tropical travel retreats where guests enjoy – endure? – nine hours of couples therapy in between massages and Ayurvedic meals. Boots now sells a clitoral suction stimulator alongside its meal deals.
Intimate care products (to clean vulvas and vaginas) make up a hefty proportion of the market, with the most successful now positioning themselves as “microbiome-balancing body care”, rather than soap, to bleach out your feminine funk. “The vulva is skin and women want it cared for with the same science and respect as their faces – not hidden on a bottom shelf in an aisle called ‘feminine hygiene’,” says Luna Daily founder Katy Cottam. “When we surveyed more than 1,000 women before launch, the thing that came through was frustration. They didn’t want to be ‘fixed’ or made to smell like a flower; they wanted products that work with their bodies, that they can trust.” Since launching in 2022, Luna has sold more than a million bottles of its hero product, Spray-to-Wipe (it comes in a display-friendly curved pastel container). “The line between sexual wellness, intimate care and everyday body care is disappearing,” says Cottam. “And that’s a good thing.” But the industry is in flux and she sees bad actors “deliberately taking advantage of women’s confusion about their own anatomy. Most of us were never taught the difference between the vulva and the vagina, and that gap is being monetised.” For example, “I see lubricant brands launch with ‘for external use’ on packaging as it means they can sidestep the expensive process of registering as a medical device, knowing full well that most women will use a lubricant for internal use. It’s dangerous.”
One of the largest sectors of the industry is supplements, with sexual wellness now occupying its own niche within existing categories, such as hormonal health and stress support. Up to 70 per cent of men experience some form of sexual dysfunction during their lives and, partly due to embarrassment about talking to their doctors, many turn to over-the-counter (or over-the-internet) supplements. Women are increasingly doing the same. According to one US survey of 12,529 participants, more than 70 per cent of adults take more than one dietary supplement daily. According to a review in the International Society for Sexual Medicine’s journal, the top-selling nutraceuticals, meaning products that come from food, designed for men’s sexual health contain a blend of multiple supplements. They found up to 33 in a single formulation, largely intended to improve function and arousal by supporting blood flow with substances such as ginseng and horny goat weed. Some must be swallowed by tossing the head back and wincing, others are in gummies that are positioned as erotic Haribos. Women’s supplements typically promise to help with low libido, using “natural solutions” such as herbs or vitamins including maca and ginkgo biloba.
The women’s market overlaps the men’s but has, in recent years, seen an additional boost. This stems from increased consumer awareness that women’s sexual health has long been under-researched and their health complaints often dismissed. A void in care can be deeply profitable.
So how do you know when a sexual wellness supplement “works”? For men, it’s fairly simple to measure. For women, are we talking about wanting to have sex for the first time in months – or years? Are we talking about a simple increase in desire? How big an increase? How do we gauge that? An increase in orgasms? The first orgasm ever? And what does it tell us about our culture that low libido has become such a powerful marketing hook?
“Libido is a powerful marketing cudgel because it can make people feel ‘less than’,” says Dr Florence Comite, an endocrinologist and leading voice in longevity. “Having a low libido is embarrassing; people don’t want to talk about it. When issues are driven into the shadows, scammers thrive.” She always encourages clinicians she trains to treat people as a “whole system”. “In today’s world we have a loneliness epidemic more than a libido crisis.” And, as yet, there’s no pill for that.
One concern about something as tricky to pin down as libido is that women might feel pressure to buy products to fix a problem that doesn’t necessarily exist. Another concern, in an unregulated industry where there have been very few clinical trials, is the threat of disinformation. In 2018, for instance, Goop was forced to pay $145,000 in civil penalties for claiming that jade love eggs would balance hormones, increase bladder control and regulate menstrual cycles. They cannot. Before that, a 2015 review of the top-selling supplements for men’s sexual health, published in The Journal of Sexual Medicine, found “little or no evidence to support claims they could improve aspects of sexual performance”. An article titled “Can Supplements Save Your Sex Life?” published by Harvard Medical School, further explained that some “natural” sexual function supplements “may contain potentially dangerous impurities or small amounts of hidden pharmaceutical drugs”, such as traces of Viagra, which can produce life-threatening reactions. At best, said urologist Dr Michael O’Leary in the article, these supplements have a placebo effect.
Which, in fact, is not nothing – although it brings further complications, especially when it comes to such a slippery metric as desire. Studies show that higher prices and fancy labels, as well as claims of particularly high dosages, increase how well a placebo works – an explanation, perhaps, for why so many sexual wellness supplements are so high-priced. And why, despite the lack of evidence, plenty of consumers using supplements still report an improvement in desire and performance. You could argue that, in many cases, all people have to lose is their cash.
For those who smell a grift when perusing corners of today’s sexual wellness industry, it’s worth remembering that this is a trade almost as old as sex itself. Renowned gynaecologist Dr Jen Gunter, famous for debunking Goop’s claims, once told me a story about a man called John Brinkley, who toured his “medicine show” through rural towns in the US in the early 1900s selling a homemade sex tonic. With a freshly purchased diploma in “eclectic medicine”, he set up a business injecting coloured water into men concerned about their virility and then (having bought a local radio station so he could advertise without disturbance) another business transplanting glands from goat testicles into those who were “sexually weak” or, as wellness product marketers might now say, suffering from “adrenal fatigue”.
There is a reason why elements of the sexual wellness landscape remain the same as they were in 1900. It’s much easier to “buy” the promise of an elevated libido than it is to try to change a life in which depression, anxiety, sleep disturbance, communication gaps, caring responsibilities and unequal divisions of labour are suppressing desire. Women have been destabilised by being repeatedly told we need to improve and optimise, but rarely are we told that periods of low libido are nothing to worry about or that receptive desire (when sexual interest is not always spontaneous) is normal. “We should be cautious about positioning sexual wellbeing as something we can commodify or purchase,” says Gurney, “rather than something that has wider political and social underpinnings, which might be tackled more effectively by examining our own pursuit of autonomy in sex, expectation of pleasure in sex or sense of safety in sex.”
Which makes perfect sense. Comite says that while it’s virtually impossible to know what you are actually getting, absorbing and metabolising when taking supplements, approaching sexual wellness more laterally can make a difference. “With an open and transparent conversation and proper medical guidance, there are plenty of non-invasive treatments available today.” Small but promising studies are showing that fenugreek, panax ginseng and maca can increase libido and arousal. Ultimately she’s just pleased we are actually talking about it. “The one thing I’ve not seen help the problem? Shame and silence. Sex is a vital part of human relationships. How do you think you got here?”