Would A Staggered Age Of Consent Protect Women And Girls?

Image may contain David Walliams Russell Brand Courtney Love Liza Tarbuck Clothing Coat Jacket Blazer Face and Head

I’m starting to lose count of the number of conversations I’ve had over the past couple of weeks with women all saying the same thing. They’re reassessing the relationships they had as teenagers, with men a decade their senior, or more, and seeing them clearly as grooming, exploitation and abuse. Or at least, as one told me, considering about the “blurriness” of it for the first time. Even that word “relationship” is taking on a new meaning – this is not age-gap relationships we’re talking about, it’s grown adults having sex with teenagers.

It’s tough stuff to think about. One friend admitted to me that she’d never questioned her years-long relationship with a man in his late 20s, which began in her mid-teens, as “technically it was legal”. Now she’s rethinking the entire thing. 

So I can see why campaigners are calling for a staggered age of consent that would leave 16 and 17-year-olds free to have sex with each other – and people close to them in age – but make it illegal with older adults. The proposal is backed by Mia Latter, who has waived her right to anonymity to speak about the “relationship” she had, aged 16, with a then 30-year-old Russell Brand, who picked her up on the street after a trip to Topshop. She says that he later orally raped her (which he denies). 

The Government has said that it’s considering changing the law and, on one level, it seems like common sense. As Latter put it: “If you’re between the ages of 16 and 18, it seems reasonable that you can have relationships with each other, and [teenagers] are always going to. But if you’re in your 30s, 40s and 50s and you’re trying to have a relationship with someone under the age of 18, it [should be] a criminal offence.”

But then… rape is a criminal offence and people still do it. The police record about 204 rapes in England and Wales every day, the vast majority women. And that’s without taking into account those who don’t report what’s happened to them for all the reasons that won’t change just because a staggered age of consent is added to the law books: shame, blame, fear, problems and delays within the justice system.

I worry that it’s a bit like slapping a tiny plaster over a gaping wound. Yes, it would be a step forward, but it can’t be the only step and the danger is that we conflate changing the law with having solved the problem. Box ticked. Done. Naturally, the cynic in me thinks that it’s almost exactly a year since the government announced its 10-year VAWG (Violence Against Women and Girls) strategy – what a convenient conversation for it to be having publicly 12 months in, with nothing concrete actually done.

There’s no doubt that things need improving – and fast. I was struck by Joanne Young, who was drugged and advertised online for sex by her husband, and for which four men have just been convicted of sexual assault. She said that her case raises “serious questions” about how our laws deal with consent, as her attackers were able to claim that they were tricked by her husband that she was a willing participant. Consent, she said, “has to come from the person themselves.” 

So would a staggered age of consent benefit women and girls? In some ways. As things stand, if you want to prosecute an adult who abused you at 16 or 17, the burden is on you to prove that you didn’t consent and were groomed. Changing the law might also put pressure on other adults to come forward and report something illegal, rather than remaining complicit. It could help teenagers to recognise what’s happening to them in real time, rather than – as many women have experienced in the past few days – decades later. But also, if my parents, or even the law, had told me who I could date as a teenager, would I have listened? Would you? 

What about healthy sex and relationships education that teaches young people to recognise grooming, coercive control and a set of behaviours often used by abusers? What about systemic change that encourages women to report? How about an end to court delays or allowing defence barristers to use “rape myths” in court? Or actually charging and prosecuting more than three per cent of the men who are reported for rape each year, rather than giving them the impression they’ll probably get away with it. 

Or how about trying to change a culture that still fetishises schoolgirls? I don’t think we’ve come all that far since Britney’s “Baby One More Time” video and the men drooling over the countdown to her 18th birthday. Perhaps that stuff has just moved out of the tabloids and online instead. 

It also ignores sexual violence by teenage boys towards teenage girls, which campaigners and schools say is a growing problem. Just because two people are legally of age, doesn’t make such behaviours admissible – as we full well know. The issue here is with sexual violence, grooming, coercion and abuse – we can’t risk turning this into a numbers game. 

One thing is for sure: things can’t stay as they are. If #MeToo was the cultural watershed that got women talking about everything we’ve experienced in our lives, this is the moment for action and law change. A staggered age of consent could be one answer – but it can’t be the only one. 

Original source Would A Staggered Age Of Consent Protect Women And Girls?

Back to home