‘You Can See Everything’ Is The Film Of The Year

Image may contain Elizabeth Holmes Face Head Person Photography Portrait Happy Smile Adult Selfie and Body Part

By now, I suspect, you will have already seen and heard plenty about the new Elizabeth Holmes documentary, . Produced by A24, directed by ’s Nathan Fielder and ’s Lance Oppenheim, and a closely-guarded secret up until its surprise premiere at Telluride, it’s been taking the US by storm over the past month or so – and very soon, it’ll be our turn on this side of the pond to dive deep into this bonkers story. So, is it worth the hype? By my reading, absolutely.

You might wonder if you need to have a working understanding of the Elizabeth Holmes phenomenon to fully appreciate it. If you’ve already binged and inhaled the many documentaries, podcasts and books about this Silicon Valley sensation who founded the blood-testing company Theranos and then spectacularly fell from grace, then, sure, you’re basically guaranteed to be obsessed with . But, even if you know next to nothing, I find it hard to believe that you won’t get swept up in it all the same. This is a movie about this 2010s girl boss-turned-convicted fraudster, but also one which is about the nature of documentary filmmaking, the ethics of fictionalising actual events, the hazy differences between reality and performance, and the elusive nature of truth. It is, without doubt, one of the most interesting, compelling films I’ve ever seen, and probably also one of the best I’ve watched in a long, long time. Possibly ever.

If you’ve gotten this far without being spoiled, please, please try to keep it that way. All I’ll say is that this story opens in San Diego in 2023, some 34 days before Holmes is set to begin her 11-year prison term at a minimum-security federal institution in Bryan, Texas. She and her partner, tech bro Billy Evans, have invited Fielder and Oppenheim to document their final days together as a family. They play with their two young kids and take pains to present the filmmakers with “the real Liz”. But, what they term “radical transparency” feels like an extended, committed but sometimes shaky performance. They want us to see them as parents, as entrepreneurs brimming with new ideas, as figures who’ve been unfairly maligned and need to be reexamined from a fresh perspective, akin to Hollywood’s obsession with reframing historic villains as products of their circumstance or, often, ahead-of-their-time feminists (, East of Eden, Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story). But, when Fielder asks simple questions which poke holes in this assumed project, Holmes and Evans leave the room. When the camera zooms in on them from afar, they look almost like different people. The masks fall, though not completely.

Image may contain Elizabeth Holmes Lighting Photography Person Architecture Building Hospital Adult and Indoors

You could probably write several books about everything that happens next. In a bid to get closer to the couple, Fielder, at their invitation, moves into their beachside rental house. (It’s unclear why his room has just a mattress and no bedding. Is it an oversight or are mind games being played?) Elizabeth’s concerned parents visit, and seem visibly uncomfortable about the performance of family unity being staged around them. Holmes, who speaks about Theranos for the first time in seven years, still appears to believe that she’s done nothing wrong. Then, Evans drives her to prison.

After this – which, in the hands of different, more conventional filmmakers, could’ve been the end of this story – the movie takes a wild left turn and just gets weirder, knottier and more fascinating. Like an even more mindbending version of (if that’s possible), we drop down through layer upon layer of performance and interpretation, until we have absolutely no idea what to think. I kept trying to guess where all this was going and getting it wrong. There are big laughs and sequences which are bloodcurdlingly tense. There’s a moment where I cried, and then felt shocked at myself for crying. There’s a twist which played like one of the most famous scenes in Alfred Hitchcock’s . And the ending, which genuinely gave me goosebumps, offers us so much to get our teeth into without giving us the definitive answers we were beginning to think we might be getting. It’s not an ending, really – just the jumping off point for you to then go to a bar with all of your friends for several hours and break down everything you just saw.

Image may contain Elizabeth Holmes Head Person Face Happy Smile Adult and Laughing

Critics have described this project as a distillation of the kind of work that Fielder, in particular, has been doing for a long time. Watch the very funny and often painfully meta or and you’ll see the roots of his out-of-the-box, clawing-to-get-under-the-skin-of-human-nature approach – but here, it’s focused instead of scatty, a little more self-aware, smarter and still bark-out-loud hilarious. ( would also make a great double feature with Oppenheim’s Robert Pattinson-led – a lesser film, but one which rumbles with the same tensions around bringing real stories and real-life people to the screen.)

It’s also worth adding that is incredibly well made. If a documentary works, it’s most often because of its subject rather than the artistry behind it, but in this case it’s a masterful melding of both. Its cinematography is steely and precise, its close-ups horrifyingly close, and the digital film somehow flinty and cold, as it captures waves crashing ceaselessly onto the shore just beyond the windows of Holmes and Evans’s rental. The rumbling music is deeply unsettling. The editing is fantastic, lingering on Holmes’s unblinking face and hanging on to Evans’s prolonged, awkward, meaningful pauses. (It’s also a wonder how the film flies by, despite being almost three hours long.) All in all, I found it more cinematic – in the transportive, mind-blowing, punch-to-the-gut sense – than any of the big-budget spectacles I’ve witnessed this year.

Image may contain Elizabeth Holmes Camera Electronics Video Camera Photography Computer Laptop Pc Adult and Person

As heads into awards season, it deserves attention for all of these individual craft elements and more. Could it actually go up against the likes of and and claim the Best Picture Oscar? It would be totally unprecedented – but I certainly hope it has a shot. That battle would typify the conflict that currently lies at the heart of Hollywood – an industry fearful of its future in a rapidly changing world, which has come to rely on very expensive IP-driven behemoths. But among those giants, there are also films like this – fresh, original stories which bend and subvert and play with the notion of what a film can be; in this case, a $7 million-budget experiment which has already made nearly $100 million, and is still yet to be released in most international territories. I’ve spent much of the past year despairing about the state of cinema – now that has almost singlehandedly turned things around, I plan to talk about little else for the next four months, in the run-up to the Academy Awards in March. Apologies in advance.

You Can See Everything is in cinemas in the UK from 20 November.

Original source ‘You Can See Everything’ Is The Film Of The Year

Back to home